Question #3640

Can someone explain why B is incorrect and why E is correct?

Started by Kweb1016 · started 2021-04-13 20:02 · last activity 2024-09-27 01:18 · 1 reply

From my perspective, the passage author is arguing that the opposing position regarding robots is that they will eliminate ALL demeaning work. I arrived at this because of the word liberate; to me, this word feels absolute, not relative, and that is why I didn't choose E. B, though not perfect, I felt was better because he essentially says that robots will require demeaning work for them to work, so demeaning work cannot be made extinct. It sounds circular, if I assume liberate equals all demeaning work will be eliminated, not some. Sorry for the long reply. Thanks

Replies

  1. Emil-Kunkin · 2024-09-27 01:18

    I agree that there is a slight incongruity between the term eliminate and the passage- but it does still point out an issue with the argument. The author thinks that they won't eliminate something bad, they will only substitute it for something else bad. The argument is still incorrect for the second part- that it only substitutes. We can attack that rationale by showing that it does not only substitute, it actually reduces the amount. Im not sure how I see how this would be circular. The author didn't say if can never be extinct, only that robots will not eliminate it.

Sign in to reply.