Clarification

Started by tselimovic · started 2015-02-01 01:44 · last activity 2017-11-28 05:02 · 4 replies

In negating answer choice D, you would negate "Warblers often share" as opposed to "which often do not". Correct?

Replies

  1. Naz · 2015-02-03 21:49

    Exactly! Great work.
  2. sharpen7 · 2017-11-17 19:18

    Why is C correct - how do we know there are no birds other than yellow warblers that compete with yellow warblers for food?
  3. sharpen7 · 2017-11-17 19:24

    Is it because the conclusion says yellow warblers have no competition for the food supply?
  4. Mehran · 2017-11-28 05:02

    Hey @sharpen7, thanks for your post. You may have misread this Strengthen With Necessary Premise question as a Must Be True question. We do not know there are no birds other than yellow warblers competing with yellow warblers for food - but that is the unstated assumption on which the argument in the stimulus relies. Without this unstated assumption, the stimulus's conclusion - that yellow warblers "have no competition for the food supply within the range of their restricted flying" - would not hold. Thus, (C) is the necessary premise needed to strengthen the argument. And this is why it is the correct answer. Hope this helps.

Sign in to reply.