Why is E correct?

Could someone explain this question to me?

@Shiyi-Zhang, Happy to help! This question is asking us to identify the main point of the passage. On these types of questions, it's always helpful to try to anticipate the main point of the passage immediately after reading it because this question is almost always asked. In the passage, we're presented with 3 formulations of the "classical" social psychological theory of social movement. The passage then shifts to criticizing these formulations (first by political theorists, and then empirically by the author). Now that we've identified the main gist of the passage, let's look at the answers. (A) is incorrect because it fails to discuss how the passage mentions that the social psychological theories have problems. (B) is incorrect because the author doesn't present a new model; rather, she's focused on tearing down old ones. (C) is incorrect because there is no shift in theoretical debate that is mentioned by the author. (D) is incorrect because although it's true, it's confined to the second paragraph and is the main purpose of that paragraph. However, (D) is too limited in scope and doesn't factor in the other things that this passage is about. The rest of the passage tears down the social psychological theories. (E) is correct because it says that the main purpose of the passage is to discuss the reasoning behind and shortcomings of certain social psychological theories. This matches up well with the what we anticipated the main point answer saying, so it's our correct answer choice. The reasoning of the certain social psychological theories is contained in the second and third paragraphs, and the shortcomings of these theories are described in the third and fourth paragraphs. This is the correct choice. Does this make sense? Let us know if you have any more questions!

I am not sure how you can reconcile the claim that “there is no shift in theoretical debate that is mentioned by the author” against this quote from lines 5-8: “New theories of social movements are being discussed, not just among psychologists, but also among political theorists.” I was between choices C and E but ultimately decided on the former on the basis of that quote. E seemed wrong because it failed to discuss the political theorists' point of view. I am still not entirely sure why C is a weaker answer than E. Please advise.

Hi @JeremyG - I just see a blank question. Can you repost please?

Hi Jacob, reposting: I am not sure how you can reconcile the claim that “there is no shift in theoretical debate that is mentioned by the author” against this quote from lines 5-8: “New theories of social movements are being discussed, not just among psychologists, but also among political theorists.” I was between choices C and E but ultimately decided on the former on the basis of that quote. E seemed wrong because it failed to discuss the political theorists' point of view. I am still not entirely sure why C is a weaker answer than E. Please advise.

Hi @JeremyG - You question posted as another blank. There may be a technical issue. Please direct any support related issues to our support staff by tapping "support" from the left menu or by calling 855.483.7862 ext. 2 Monday-Friday 9am-6pm PT. I hope this helps!