Q20
Started by
Marshall98
· started 2020-08-25 17:13
· last activity 2020-09-13 17:55
· 1 reply
why is it not possible for x to be in the second spoonful with "U"? Leaving Y by itself in the third spoonful and T,W, and Z together in the first spoonful?
-
Victoria
· 2020-09-13 17:55
Hi @Marshall98,
Happy to help!
X cannot be in the second spoonful with U as you've set up above because of Rule 4 which tells us that U is in the same spoonful as either Y or Z but not both.
The question stem tells us that Z is in the first spoonful and Rule 1 tells us that U must be later than T. This means that Y must be in the same spoon as U which cannot be the first spoonful.
If we put T in the first spoonful with Z, U must be in either spoons 2 or 3.
Option 1 - U in spoon 2
Rule 4 tells us that Y must be in the same spoon as U and Rule 3 tells us that Y must be later than W. Therefore, W must be in the first spoonful and X must be in the third.
1: T Z W
2: U Y
3: X
Option 2 - U in spoon 3
Rule 4 tells us that Y must be in the same spoon as U. Rule 2 means that U cannot be later than X so X must also be in spoon 3, meaning that W must be in spoon 2 as all three spoons must have at least one letter.
1: T Z
2: W
3: U Y X
If we put T in the second spoonful, then Rules 1 and 4 mean that U and Y must be in spoon 3. Again, Rule 2 tells us that U cannot be later than X, so X must be in spoon 3. The W can go in either spoons 1 or 2.
1: Z
2: T
3: U Y X
Notice in the above that X must always be in the third spoonful, making answer choice (E) our correct answer.
Hope this helps! Please let us know if you have any further questions.
Sign in to reply.