Answer Choice C

Started by nelson316 · started 2020-08-13 01:32 · last activity 2023-03-18 00:05 · 7 replies

The first rule states that if PY----RPYR In answer choice C, R only comes after the PY, not before. Is there reason why there is an exception to the rule? Is it because the strand starts with PY? I could just be confusing myself.

Replies

  1. shunhe · 2020-08-13 16:48

    Hi @nelson316, Thanks for the question! So this one is a bit tricky and requires some careful reading of the rule, but this isn’t an exception to the rule. Let’s take a look at the relevant text, which tells us that “if a purple bead is adjacent to a yellow bead, any bead that immediately follows and any bead that immediately precedes that pair must be red.” What is that telling us? Well, it there’s PY, then the bead before and after will be red. But does it tell us that there has to be a bead before or after? No, not necessarily! And that’s the trick to this one. So as you noted, it’s because PY is at the front. The rule doesn’t say, “if a purple bead is adjacent to a yellow bead, there’s a bead that immediately follows and a bead that immediately precedes that pair, and they must be red.” It’s more like “if there’s PY, and if there’s a bead before/after, then those beads are red.” But there doesn’t need to be a bead before or after, so PY could be at the beginning or end. Hope this helps! Feel free to ask any other questions that you might have.
  2. AJamesIII · 2021-04-14 12:47

    Very tricky. Thanks for the response Shunhe. I had the same thought process as Keeley.
  3. NULL · 2021-11-18 04:16

    I had this same thought!
  4. NULL · 2021-12-28 18:28

    Good to know!
  5. Ravi · 2022-02-11 13:07

    Happy to know you guys see it clearly now.
  6. NULL · 2023-03-14 18:58

    here for the same reason. this will 100% trick most people bc we are being trained to look for these types of tricks and so we apply rules where they dont belong sometimes. even careful reading of this didnt help me as i assumed that correctly at first then changed my mind due to overthinking xD
  7. Emil-Kunkin · 2023-03-18 00:05

    I certainly see you about the overthinking aspect! One general rule I like to use for games is that if the game doesn't tell you something is banned, than you're allowed to do it.

Sign in to reply.