Question #1245

Answer choice D

Started by Hanfan · started 2022-09-09 22:10 · last activity 2023-01-15 22:19 · 4 replies

I know it has been elaborated on why e is wrong and d is right. the reason i crossed it out has not been mentioned yet. I got rid of D because the passage said that the foreign part may be unreliable and that you shouldn't take the risk of not choosing Clarks, meaning that some foreign parts are reliable. this would mean that there was a possibility that foreign parts were as good as or better than the government standards. is it because it notes the 'cheap' foreign parts? even then it seems it could be cheap but still reliable? let me know what you think

Replies

  1. Hanfan · 2022-09-29 20:35

    Hello, Just following up!

  2. Emil-Kunkin · 2022-11-28 19:50

    Hi, I think this would be a valid reason to eliminate D as well.

  3. Hanfan · 2023-01-11 06:33

    Hi emil, I believe D is the correct answer. Considering my reasoning why should I not have eliminated D?

  4. Emil-Kunkin · 2023-01-15 22:19

    Oh wow, good point! I think the first lesson here is when pasting in my answers, I should check which one I'm responding to. I would first want to point out that I don't think we know for sure that some foreign parts are reliable. We know there is uncertainty, but we have no idea if any are necessarily reliable. For a necessary assumption question like this, I would aim to treat it as a must be true. Sure, it is possible that there are some high quality foreign parts, but their existence has no bearing on d. D is explicitly only talking about the cheap one, so the existence of good foreign parts is completely irrelevant.

Sign in to reply.