"Did Not Exceed" in C

Started by Julie-V · started 2019-07-15 17:20 · last activity 2019-07-30 21:20 · 1 reply

Hi LSAT Max! I'm still a little confused with this stimulus and correct answer choice. I know that the cause is the experimenter concluding that fusion has been achieved because the effect was a measurable amount of h-4 gas found in the air of the chamber. When I first picked C, I thought that "did not exceed" meant that there wasn't enough h-4 gas which is why it weakens. After reading the explanation and answer choice C about five more times, however, I think "did not exceed" references to the fact that the h-4 gas was either the same amount or less than what is typically found in ordinary air. Since there's no difference in h-4 gas between the experiment and generally with ordinary air, does that lead us to believe that the presence of h-4 gas isn't enough to prove that fusion has been achieved? I hope I didn't lose you there with my question. Any clarifications would be greatly appreciated. Many thanks in advance!

Replies

  1. Ravi · 2019-07-30 21:20

    @Julie-V, Great question. Recall that we're looking to cast doubt on the experimenters' conclusion. That's correct. If the amount of h-4 gas in the chamber isn't greater than what's found in the atmosphere, this casts a ton of doubt that fusion was actually achieved. What's to say that the h-4 present in the chamber isn't the same naturally-occurring h-4 in the atmosphere and wasn't a byproduct of the reaction? This makes the claim that fusion occurred very questionable, so (C) is the correct answer choice. Does this make sense? Let us know if you have any other questions!

Sign in to reply.