How Is Answer Choice A Incorrect?
Started by
Kimberlydo4413
· started 2018-03-31 18:10
· last activity 2018-04-03 06:37
· 1 reply
I understand that the conclusion is that since there is no evidence of life outside of Earth, there must be no life elsewhere. So a direct attack to the reasoning is that there is other life other than life we know of on Earth. How is A wrong?
-
rweyer
· 2018-04-03 06:37
The biggest issue that it seems you are having is understanding the stimulus. You could attack his reasoning, but it doesn't give him a reason to reconsider his conclusion. Just because someone tells you there IS life on other planets doesn't mean that I would have to reconsider my conclusion that there ISNT. Answer C does exactly that, it gives him a reason to reconsider his conclusion.
Sign in to reply.